Surface Science and

Nano-Tribology Laboratory

 

Carbon nanotubes have attracted great interest since they were first synthesized in 1991. The tubes have substantial promise in a variety of applications due to their unique mechanical and electronic properties. Efforts have been made to characterize the mechanical properties of carbon nanotubes, experimentally and theoretically. However, previous work has concentrated on the tubes’ longitudinal properties, and studies of their radial properties lag behind.  We used a scanning probe microscope with an indentation/scratch function to investigate the radial compression of multiwalled carbon nanotubes under an asymmetric stress.  In particular, we have determined the radial compressive elastic modulus at different compression levels, and estimated the compressive strength to be well beyond 5.3GPa.

 

Fig. 1. The AFM image of CNT taken in the tapping mode (size: 2mm ´ 2mm).

 

       

    

Fig. 2. Manipulation of the tubes using the indentation/scratching function of the NanoScopeTM IIIa.  All images are 500nm by 500nm.

(a) Tapping mode image of tubes before manipulation. 
(b) After knocking the overlapping tubes at point A, one end of the  
     upper tube slipped off the lower one.
(c) Making a scratch at the surface of the substrate from point B along
     the direction indicated in (b) completely separated the two tubes. 
(d) Making a scratching from C to D as shown in (c) pulled the upper
     tube further away from the lower one.
 

Fig. 3. The AFM image

u To estimate the compression strength of the tube, we used excessive forces, in spite of substrate indentation.  We have tried to break the tubes with a force as large as 20µN for more than two dozen times, but did not succeed. It is a further evidence that the carbon nanotubes are remarkably resilient due to its hexagonal network structure. The tubes can sustain extreme compression with no signs of breaking, plasticity or atomic rearrangements. 
u This figure shows a restored nanotube sitting on top of an indent between the pile-ups caused by indenting on silicon wafer substrate, which was made by a 20µN force exerted by the tip through the compressed and flattened tube. Based on the dimension of the indent, the tube was bent to an angle of about 50° during indenting, in addition to the extreme compression.  According to the forces we used in the trials and the size of the indents, the compressive strength of the nanotubes should be beyond 5.3Gpa.
 

       

Fig. 4. The AFM images

  Using the scratching function to stretch the tubes in their middle section along the direction perpendicular to their axis with the two ends more or less fixed or blocked, we have broken the tubes for several times. This suggests that longitudinal stretch strength of the tubes may not be as strong as the radial compressive strength.